- Joined
- Sep 14, 2011
- Messages
- 238
You'll be amazed how much effort & thought already has been lost on this season ... even when this was limited to the perverted situation that existed in HW Singles. Yet it would be callous when I show no support for Steel. So as far as Doubles is concerned ... my vote will always respect Steels wishes.
In short about all weights: KFD already stepped in & the call he made is the same for all. His solutions were used in all other weights before HW Doubles and we probably need him to reach a decision in LW Singles too (has been dead for 2 months). The majority decides: play on or not. Do you feel that this solution is unfair? Imao, you'll need to provide very good reasons when you like that the winning condition in all the Weights = 10 wins & dispute every decision taken:
- Light Weight Doubles: 3 wins
- Middle Weight Doubles: 5 wins
- Heavy Weights Doubles: 7 wins ???
- Light Weight Singles: 5 wins ???
- Middle Weights Singles: 7 wins
- Heavy Weights Singles: 7 wins
Forcing everyone in all the different weights to reach the same winning condition as HW Doubles sounds fun, even when you decide that 7 wins is enough. Yet it's more likely that shit will meet fan and that you'll alienate more & more players while this season keeps you hostage. Even if you're a stickler for rules, you'll have to admit that KFD can choose a more reasonable solution as referee (this has already worked in every weight class). HW Doubles seems to be headed for a winning condition of 10 wins: making that weight class the only exception instead of being the rule ... I still prefer to end the season "properly" & "timely" by voting for the possibility that causes the least harm and that respects the objective meaning of the words between quotation marks better.
BTW that a season drags on should be a concern of you too. This season is already 5 months old (since sign-ups opened). Very long seasons will scare a lot of players or many will lose interest when they have to wait till the current one ends. A good tournament has a reasonable timeframe so that more of us join, everyone stays involved (instead of all who dropped out/grew tired of this season) and most like to return for a new season. That players can get tired/lack the joy needed to continue endangers the longevity of any tournament. So it matters how long a season lasts when you like the Belt to be a mainstay of MajCom.
In short about all weights: KFD already stepped in & the call he made is the same for all. His solutions were used in all other weights before HW Doubles and we probably need him to reach a decision in LW Singles too (has been dead for 2 months). The majority decides: play on or not. Do you feel that this solution is unfair? Imao, you'll need to provide very good reasons when you like that the winning condition in all the Weights = 10 wins & dispute every decision taken:
- Light Weight Doubles: 3 wins
- Middle Weight Doubles: 5 wins
- Heavy Weights Doubles: 7 wins ???
- Light Weight Singles: 5 wins ???
- Middle Weights Singles: 7 wins
- Heavy Weights Singles: 7 wins
Forcing everyone in all the different weights to reach the same winning condition as HW Doubles sounds fun, even when you decide that 7 wins is enough. Yet it's more likely that shit will meet fan and that you'll alienate more & more players while this season keeps you hostage. Even if you're a stickler for rules, you'll have to admit that KFD can choose a more reasonable solution as referee (this has already worked in every weight class). HW Doubles seems to be headed for a winning condition of 10 wins: making that weight class the only exception instead of being the rule ... I still prefer to end the season "properly" & "timely" by voting for the possibility that causes the least harm and that respects the objective meaning of the words between quotation marks better.
BTW that a season drags on should be a concern of you too. This season is already 5 months old (since sign-ups opened). Very long seasons will scare a lot of players or many will lose interest when they have to wait till the current one ends. A good tournament has a reasonable timeframe so that more of us join, everyone stays involved (instead of all who dropped out/grew tired of this season) and most like to return for a new season. That players can get tired/lack the joy needed to continue endangers the longevity of any tournament. So it matters how long a season lasts when you like the Belt to be a mainstay of MajCom.